Sugar Shane’s

Grace Beasley a month ago

Guyelle was the sweetest & kindest person. She welcomed my friend & I since it was our first time at the shop yesterday. They had a sale 4 for $20, the cookies are humongous so you most definitely get your money’s worth. I bought the biscoff cookie, dark brown sugar toffee, chocolate chip cookie, & s’mores cookie. My ultimate favorite cookie is the dark brown sugar toffee. The chocolate chip has a great balance of salty & sweetness (it was topped with sea salt to help cut up the sweetness). The s’mores cookie was good, soft, & fluffy. I haven’t tried the biscoff cookie yet, but I’m sure it will be amazing just as the other cookies are. Overall, I had a great experience & would recommend people to come try their cookies.

Christine Kennedy 2 months ago

Just average cookies and desserts. We tried the chocolate chip and smore cookies both were just ok. The banana bread was good. The monkey bread topped with frosting should be considered a weapon. My fork wouldn't even go through it. I arrived 20 minutes after opening so you'd think they would be fresh. The strawberry short cake cinnamon roll had the same hard texture as the monkey bread. Maybe I went on a off day.

Jonathan Lee 6 months ago

Great cookies and kind staff! Sugar Shane’s has fun cookie flavors along with other rotating treats. When I went, they had the classic cookies, some weekly offerings, and massive cinnamon rolls. I tried the chocolate chip and the oatmeal créme pie. The chocolate chip was your classic brown butter dough with rich chocolate, crispy edges, and a chewy center. Sea salt flakes are always a nice touch as well. It was a great cookie and hit all the marks, but it was missing that x-factor that makes some cookies mind blowing. For me, the oatmeal crème pie was the highlight. The oatmeal cookies were really sugary and had a toasted caramel flavor. They were the perfect vessel for the smooth, subtly tangy buttercream. The sweetness contrasted well with the nutty earthiness of the crispy cookies. I’m sure you can’t go wrong with the any offering at Sugar Shane’s, so if you’re in Sandy Springs, make sure to make a stop!

Andrew Beam 6 months ago

Absolutely the best cookies in the Atlanta area! Massive cookies at not a bad price! There's hardly room to stand in this one, so be prepared to grab your cookies and go, but their rotating selection of fresh, jumbo cookies always hits the spot! Keep an eye out for one of these when you're around Atlanta

John Rodriguez 7 months ago

Stopped in for the first time ever for a late-night treat and was blown away by the desserts and flavors. It was great to meet Shane himself and hear more about how they got started. Despite being late, they gave awesome recommendations and the cookies were fresh and tasty. You can tell Shane and his team put their heart into what they do and it definitely comes through in their desserts. An incredible small business that I’d recommend to everyone! Y’all have a new fan!